ISO/IEC JTC1/SC22/WG15 (Posix) Meeting, Annapolis, USA October 1993 Meeting Report 0. Introduction: Twenty-three delegates from Germany, the Netherlands, the US, the UK, Canada, Denmark, Japan, Germany and the Netherlands attended the WG15 meeting in Annapolis. The agenda included sixty-eight action items and some sixty papers for consideration. The Plenary was preceded on the 25th and 26th of October by meetings of the WG15 Rapporteur Groups on Internationalisation, Conformance Testing, Security and also on Coordination of Profile Activities. 1. Plenary 1.0 ISO 9945-2: 9945-2, the 'Shell and Utilities' Posix standard, closed its DIS ballot on 6-June. A Disposition of Comments meeting was held in July, in conjunction with the IEEE PASC Posix meeting, and produced a Ballot Disposition statement, which proposed to incorporate a number of the International comments as editorial changes to the Standard, and to accept the remainder as a revised Annex H, which would form the basis of a future amendment to 9945-2. This proposal was accepted by the National Bodies whose comments were affected. Denmark was concerned that its comments on 9945-2 were not accommodated in 9945-2 due to a failure of the Synchronisation plan. At the WG15 meeting Denmark requested changes to the Plan, which involved WG15 distribution of PARs and of PASC Draft documents in the WG15 mailing on a regular basis. Denmark and the WG15 Convener were actioned to work on an updated Synchronisation Plan for consideration at the next WG15 meeting. Following the approval at the SC22 Plenary in September of the current ISO/IEC Posix and IEEE PASC Posix Synchronisation Plan, which incorporates a mechanism for handling Interpretations Requests, (otherwise known as Defect Reports or queries) it was reported that some sixty Requests were in the pipeline for 9945-1:1990 and 9945-2:1993. National Member Bodies were asked to provide nominees for a Defect Report resolution (sub-) committee. PASC IEEE is currently working on a number of the Interpretations requests. 1.1 P1003.0 'Guide': The Posix Guide TR, also known as P1003.0, was debated during the WG15 meeting in the light of criticism from SGFS amongst others. While the IEEE PASC group (which had met over the previous week) had acknowledged a problem with Draft 16 of P1003.0 - the lack of the word 'Posix' before 'OSE' throughout the document - and had proposed resubmitting Draft 15 to ISO together with a cover letter of explanation, WG15 persuaded the US that this was ill-advised. The P1003.0 technical editor produced Draft 16.1, fixing this problem, during the week and the UK member of the WG15 Profiles group was able to bring a copy home with him. 1.2 ISO Guide 25 Interpretations: WG15 considers that the document is not well applied to its area of work. The US suggested that the document is fatally flawed. WG15 resolved to ask SC21 to suspend progress of the Guide 25 until WG15 has had the opportunity to make more substantive comment on the document between now and its May 1994 meeting. WG15 Plenary produced sixty-six action items, (eleven of which will require the attention of BSI's IST/5/-/15), plus twenty-one resolutions. 2. UK Delegation: The UK delegation consisted of: David Cannon UK BSI IST/5/-/15 Convenor, PUKE (University of Exeter) Martin Kirk (X/Open Company Ltd) Colin O'Driscoll RGCT Rapporteur (NCC) Dan Chacon (BSI QA) Peter Owens RGCPA Rapporteur (CCTA) David Cannon 1-November-1993